'Good Effort' Might Be the Wrong Feedback

Here is a 100 word summary of an opinion piece I found interesting and relevant to secondary/A level teachers. And some ideas to start applying tomorrow.
Article citation:
Note: This is an opinion piece – not a research study.
100 word summary:
Carol Dweck’s article revisits growth mindset and argues that it has often been misunderstood in schools. She stresses that growth mindset is not simply about praising effort; improvement comes from effort combined with effective strategies, feedback, persistence, and learning from mistakes. Students who believe their abilities can develop are more likely to embrace challenges and setbacks as opportunities for growth. Dweck warns against a “false growth mindset,” where effort is celebrated regardless of learning outcomes. The goal is not to make students feel good temporarily, but to help them achieve genuine learning, progress, and higher attainment through continual improvement
My sample effective ‘Effort praise’ statements
Pointing to what the effort achieved
"Your last three drafts show the argument getting tighter each time. Your second paragraph now does the work your whole intro used to."
"You stuck with that proof for twenty minutes, and you've now ruled out two approaches that don't work."
Naming the strategy and what it revealed
"Drawing the diagram first showed you the problem was about ratios, not addition. What did that change for you?"
"When you reread the question aloud, you caught the word 'except.' That's a strategy worth keeping."
Giving the student something to do next
"Your flashcards got you the vocabulary, but the quiz tested usage. What could you try to practice using the words?"
"That strategy worked for the first four problems and stalled on the fifth. What's different about the fifth?"
"You asked a classmate and got unstuck. Next time, try asking yourself what you'd ask them first."
When the effort didn't produce results
"You put in a lot of time, and the result isn't there yet. That tells us the strategy needs changing, not the effort. Let's look at what you did."
My final thoughts:
Is a student failing because of a "fixed mindset", or because they lack prerequisite knowledge, feel anxious, are cognitively overloaded, or have repeatedly experienced failure?



Comments